Perspective:

ECA report underlines urgency of embedding trade compliance into business operations

Tax Dispute Resolution | Legal Newsflash

Key takeaway

Export controls and sanctions have moved from a specialist legal issue to a core business risk. The European Court of Auditors (ECA) finds that EU trade sanctions have materially reduced direct trade with Russia, but that legal ambiguity, divergent national enforcement, circumvention and fragmented information-sharing still limit their effectiveness. For companies, the direction of travel is clear: expectations around due diligence, data quality, governance and demonstrable controls are rising, while enforcement and criminal exposure are becoming more tangible.

Why this matters now

The ECA’s Special Report 30/2026: EU trade sanctions against the Russian Federation shows both progress and persistent enforcement gaps. The report notes that direct exports of common high-priority and economically critical goods to Russia have almost ceased since 2023. At the same time, sanctioned goods still reach Russia indirectly, national customs practices remain uneven and “forum-shopping” can exploit less stringent control points. These differences point to an apparent lack of a level playing field for EU exporters.

  • EU-Russia trade in goods fell from EUR 252.8 billion in 2021 to EUR 58.3 billion in 2025.
  • The estimated impact of export restrictions and bans is EUR 49 billion, or 56% of pre-war EU exports to Russia.
  • More than 12,000 sanctions-related customs Risk Information Forms have been issued since 2022, but the underlying systems are not used uniformly across Member States.

These findings should not be read as an argument for a “wait and see” approach. They point to stronger coordination, more integrated monitoring and greater use of data. The ECA recommends clearer rules, closer scrutiny of Member State enforcement, fuller use of information-exchange tools and integrated compliance tracking.

A dedicated EU sanctions office strengthens coordination with and between Member States

On 5 November 2026, European Commissioner for Financial Services, Maria Luís Albuquerque, announced the creation of a dedicated internal European Commission sanctions office. The office is intended to cover the full economic lifecycle of EU sanctions against third countries, particularly Russia, from policy design and international outreach to implementation and the prevention of circumvention. Its role is to strengthen coordination with and between Member States, provide faster guidance and improve data sharing and analysis. It is not a new EU enforcement authority and does not have an independent legal mandate to enforce sanctions; enforcement remains the responsibility of the competent national authorities. The Commission also announced an informal crypto-sanctions task force to address an increasingly important channel for circumvention.

This institutional reinforcement signals a stronger focus on consistent implementation and closer cooperation among national authorities, rather than a transfer of enforcement powers to the Commission’s new office. For businesses, the practical implication is that sanctions and export controls should be embedded in operations, not treated as a peripheral issue or managed on the assumption that enforcement gaps will persist. Better coordination, faster information flows and more effective use of data can support national enforcement and help reduce differences in application across the EU, alongside cooperation with G7 and other like-minded partners.

Data transparency will reshape the control environment

The EU Customs Reform reinforces this trend. The proposed EU Customs Data Hub and EU Customs Authority are designed to improve information-sharing and risk management across the Union. As customs data become more centralised and transparent, authorities will be better placed to identify inconsistencies across classifications, licences, routes, counterparties, end-use statements and historical declarations.

For businesses, this means that fragmented or poorly governed data will increasingly become a compliance risk in its own right. Customs, export-control and sanctions data should therefore be treated as one connected control environment. The probability that anomalies are detected is becoming more real than ever, with potentially serious operational, financial, reputational and criminal consequences.

From uneven enforcement to serious penalties

Directive (EU) 2024/1226 requires Member States to establish minimum rules on criminal offences and penalties for violations of EU restrictive measures and to strengthen enforcement. Belgium transposed the Directive through the Law of 15 July 2026 (Dutch | French), whose main provisions entered into force on 1 September 2026.

This framework illustrates the change in enforcement posture. Depending on the conduct and circumstances, violations or circumvention can result in criminal or administrative proceedings. Reported maximum criminal fines for legal persons can reach EUR 150 million, alongside confiscation and significant penalties for individuals. Corporate exposure may also arise where offences benefit the legal person or result from inadequate supervision or control.

The practical message is not that every error will become a prosecution. It is that companies must be able to demonstrate a proportionate, risk-based and operationally effective compliance framework, supported by reliable data and evidence.

What businesses should do
  • Establish clear accountability across legal, compliance, tax, supply chain, sales, procurement, finance and IT divisions.
  • Map products, software, technology, counterparties, ownership and control, destinations, routes, end-users and end-use against applicable restrictions.
  • Embed screening, licensing, escalation, contractual safeguards and recordkeeping into order-to-cash and procure-to-pay processes.
  • Connect customs, sanctions and export-control data, and test whether the same transaction tells a consistent story across systems and documents.
  • Monitor circumvention indicators, higher-risk third-country routes and the involvement of intermediaries, including brokers, resellers and distributors, and retain evidence of decisions and due diligence.
  • Prepare for audits, investigations and potential disputes before authorities request the data.
How we can help: end-to-end global trade

Advise: assess exposure; interpret sanctions, dual-use and customs rules; perform risk, governance and gap assessments; design policies, controls and remediation roadmaps.

Implement: translate requirements into scalable processes, data models and technology, including SAP GTS and S/4 integration, screening, licensing, classification and evidence-by-design.

Operate: run and improve compliance through co-sourcing, managed services, regulatory monitoring, screening, control-tower support and AI-enabled trade operations.

Litigate: prepare for audits and investigations, manage dawn raids and enforcement responses, preserve privilege and evidence, and coordinate administrative, civil and criminal defence across borders.

We combine regulatory, legal, technology, data and operational capabilities to help businesses prevent, detect, respond to and defend global trade compliance issues.